Essential Guide on How to Choose a Roofer: Smart Tips for a Solid Roof

Reading Time: 10 minutes

Are you struggling to find a roofer you can trust? Knowing how to choose a roofer is vital for your home’s integrity and your wallet. Cut through the confusion with this no-nonsense guide, ensuring your next roofer is up to the task without the guesswork. Find assurance in their credentials, confidence in their estimates, and clarity in their references—all here to make your decision solid and straightforward.

How to Choose a Roofer: Keys

Key Takeaways

  • A thorough initial inspection will help determine the specific roofing needs, whether it’s general maintenance, repairs, or a full replacement, and the type of materials suitable for the home, like asphalt shingles, PVC, or flat roofing.

  • When selecting a roofing contractor, verify their credentials, including proper licensing and insurances, and evaluate their experience and expertise to ensure high-quality workmanship and adherence to local building codes.

  • It’s important to request multiple estimates and understand the details and potential hidden costs outlined in the contract, emphasizing the importance of transparent communication for a successful project.

Assessing Your Roofing Needs

How to Choose a Roofer
How to Choose a Roofer – Brookline Flat PVC Roof

Understanding your roofing needs is the first step towards a successful roofing project. Start with a thorough roof inspection, which evaluates the gutters, layers, non-shingle elements, and debris to determine the scope of work required. This inspection will help you identify whether your roof needs general maintenance, repairs, installations, weatherproofing, insulation, or ventilating.

When deciding between repairing and replacing your roof, consider its age, past damage, and future expectations. Asking these questions and seeking multiple estimates can clarify whether a new roof is necessary or repairs will suffice. It is important to research and obtain various estimates from roofing contractors before replacing the roof. For instance, minor roof repairs can often be completed within one to three days, depending on the extent of the damage and the efficiency of the roofing contractor.

Assessing your needs also involves considering the roofing materials best suited for your home. Whether it’s asphalt shingles, metal roofing, or another material, the choice will affect the longevity and performance of your roof. By understanding your specific needs, you can make informed decisions that will save you time and money in the long run. Some common roofing materials to consider are:

  • Flat Roof
  • Asphalt shingles

  • Metal roofing

  • Clay or concrete tiles

  • Slate roofing

Common roofing materials

It’s important to research and select the material that best fits your needs and budget, as each material has its own set of advantages and disadvantages.

Identifying Quality Roofing Contractors

Finding reliable roofing contractors is crucial for ensuring quality workmanship. Start by exploring local business directories specific to your state, often providing trustworthy lists of qualified roofing contractors. Online searches can also help you create a shortlist of potential roofing contractors, offering reviews and ratings from other homeowners. When you have a list, vet and evaluate each potential roofing contractor by asking for references, checking their work, and inquiring about insurance and liability.

Additionally, consider independent roofing contractors who may offer specialized skills and provide a consistent point of contact throughout your project.

Recommendations from homeowners associations (HOAs) can be invaluable. These associations often have collective experiences with various contractors and can point you toward reputable options. Additionally, contractors with solid track records and recommendations are more likely to deliver satisfactory results, effectively addressing your specific roofing needs.

Identifying quality contractors involves more than just finding names. It’s about ensuring they have the right credentials, experience, and expertise to handle your roofing project. The following sections will delve deeper into verifying contractor credentials and evaluating their knowledge, helping you choose a roofing contractor with confidence.

Verifying Contractor Credentials

Before hiring a roofing contractor, it’s essential to verify their credentials. When considering independent roofing contractors, ensure they have the necessary licenses and insurance to protect your property and workers. Ensure the contractor is licensed, as this is a critical safeguard for homeowners. Licensed contractors are required to pass a written exam in their field, demonstrating their knowledge and capability.

Also, check if the contractor has general liability and workers’ compensation insurance. General liability insurance protects you from any property damage or accidents that might occur during the roofing project, so it’s crucial to ensure that general liability insurance protects your property. Workers’ compensation insurance prevents you from being liable for medical expenses if a worker gets injured on your property. These credentials are non-negotiable, ensuring you and your property are protected throughout the project.

Evaluating Experience and Expertise

Evaluating a contractor’s experience and expertise is another critical step. The reliability and quality of work from a roofing contractor can be gauged by how long they have been in the industry and the diversity of companies they’ve worked with. Experienced contractors can offer valuable insights into cost-effective materials and methods, whether you’re considering asphalt shingles, PVC, or TPO roofing.

Moreover, contractors must be familiar with local building codes, which prescribe specific requirements such as the type of shingle and underlayment. This knowledge is essential for accurate roofing estimates and compliance with local regulations. By evaluating experience and expertise, you can feel confident in the contractor’s ability to deliver a high-quality roofing system. Independent roofing contractors often bring specialized knowledge and a personal touch to their projects, which can benefit unique roofing styles or specific material preferences.

Requesting Multiple Estimates

Illustration of written estimates from roofing contractors

Obtaining estimates from multiple roofing contractors is crucial in choosing the right roofing contractor. Aim to get at least two or three estimates from different contractors to compare pricing, timelines, and work details. This comparison helps you make an informed decision, ensuring you get the best value for your money.

When comparing estimates, consider the specifics of removing the old roof or installing a new roof system. A complete roof replacement on an average-sized home usually takes one day, but this timeline can extend for larger homes or more complex projects. Understanding these details will help you set realistic expectations and avoid surprises during the roofing project.

Understanding Estimates and Contracts

A comprehensive roofing estimate should include:

  • An itemized list covering all tasks and materials

  • Property protection measures

  • Removal of previous layers

  • Installation methods

  • Ventilation components

  • Flashing

  • Waste disposal fees

  • Warranty details

This level of detail ensures transparency and helps you understand the full scope of work and associated costs.

Estimates should also anticipate additional costs, such as replacing a damaged roofing deck discovered during the project. Understanding the warranties for materials and workmanship is crucial, reflecting the contractor’s confidence in their work. Ensure the contract outlines payment terms, amendment procedures, lien waivers, and conditions for contract termination. An estimate lacking detail or a contractor avoiding discussing the quote can signal potential future issues due to a lack of transparency.

Decoding the Fine Print

Decoding the fine print in roofing contracts is essential to avoid unexpected costs and issues. Hidden costs may stem from factors such as:

  • the types and number of shingles

  • waste potential

  • labor hours

  • equipment rentals

  • overhead costs

  • profit margins

Understanding these elements can help you avoid surprises and budget accurately.

Be aware of the following when reviewing your roofing contract:

  • Property damage clauses in the fine print might release contractors from liability for damages incurred during the roofing process or specify exclusions for property protection responsibilities.

  • Foregone roofing warranties may reduce initial expenses but can lead to uncovered repair costs down the line.

  • Ensure your contract includes a ‘price lock’ guarantee to protect you from price changes during the project unless the scope changes.

The Importance of Communication

The Importance of Communication

Clear communication with your roofing contractor is vital for a successful project. Here are some tips to ensure clear communication:

  1. Establish reliable contact methods, including phone, email, or messaging apps.

  2. Educate yourself about the roofing process.

  3. Actively communicate any concerns during the project.

Efficient communication methods like text messaging can minimize delays and misunderstandings, enhancing customer satisfaction. Clear and consistent communication throughout the project, including post-installation, is essential to address any concerns and keep you informed. Reputable roofing companies prioritize effective communication to ensure a smooth and transparent process.

Selecting the Right Roofing Materials

Selecting the Right Roofing Materials

Choosing the right roofing materials is crucial for the longevity and performance of your roof. Here are some options to consider:

  • PVC roofs are highly durable and can withstand severe weather conditions. They are also fire-resistant and have a long lifespan.

  • Asphalt shingles: They are popular due to their affordability and versatility. They come in a variety of colors and styles.

  • Reflective materials: Reflective roofing materials can improve your home’s energy efficiency by reducing heat absorption. This can help lower your energy costs.

Consider your local climate conditions when choosing roofing materials for your existing roof.

Specialized roof replacement contractors can assist you in selecting the most appropriate roofing material for your needs and ensuring proper installation. For example, TPO roofing, known for its durability and efficiency, can be a valuable option for many homeowners. By carefully selecting the right materials, you can ensure your roof withstands the test of time and weather.

Comparing Material Lifespans and Warranties

When selecting roofing materials, consider their durability, lifespan, and warranty coverage. Here are some options to consider:

  • PVC roofing, celebrated for its durability and longevity, typically has a lifespan of up to 50 years.

  • Slate and metal roofs can last several decades with proper maintenance.

  • Materials like cedar shake have lifespans ranging from 20 to 50 years.

Warranties are a reflection of a roofing contractor’s confidence in their work. Comprehensive warranties covering both materials and workmanship support long-term roof durability and performance. Local contractors offer better warranty service due to close relationships with manufacturers and upholding warranty conditions during roofing repairs. Comparing these factors ensures you choose a material that meets your needs and budget.

Balancing Cost and Quality

Balancing cost and quality is essential when selecting roofing materials. While cheaper materials can provide initial cost savings, they often have shorter lifespans and lower durability, increasing costs over time. Materials with higher upfront costs may be more cost-effective in the long run due to their durability and extended lifespan.

For example, EPDM roofing is affordable, ranging between $4 and $8 per square foot, making it a cost-effective solution for those seeking an economical option. Though more expensive upfront, PVC roofing materials offer extended warranties and are recognized for their durability. Comparing estimates helps you find a quality roof that fits your budget and provides adequate protection over time.

Checking References and Past Work

Checking references and past work is crucial for verifying a contractor’s reliability and quality of work. Roofing contractors should provide references upon request, allowing you to verify their work. Evaluating a contractor’s portfolio and seeking visual proof, such as photos or actual inspections, provide insights into their capability and attention to detail.

Aim to obtain at least three references to understand the contractor’s past performance comprehensively. Negative reviews mentioning poor quality work or unfulfilled warranties can indicate a lack of dependability. Thoroughly checking references helps you choose a contractor you can trust.

Visiting Current Job Sites

Visiting current job sites allows you to observe a contractor’s use of equipment, safety standards, and cleanliness. High-quality equipment indicates professionalism and a commitment to efficiency, leading to better roofing results. Proper equipment also supports rigorous safety standards on job sites.

Cleanliness at the job site can reflect organized work processes facilitated by the proper equipment. These observations provide a glimpse into the contractor’s work ethic and quality, giving you confidence in their ability to complete your roofing project to a high standard.

Planning for Project Timelines and Disruptions

Planning for project timelines and potential disruptions is essential to the roofing process. Roofing projects can be completed more quickly during seasons with longer daylight hours, while shorter daylight in winter months may slow progress. Factors like landscaping, fences, and neighboring houses can also impact project duration.

Inclement weather, especially rain, can delay roof replacement projects by forcing work to be rescheduled or paused. Material shortages can lead to longer lead times and higher costs, emphasizing the importance of regular maintenance to avoid urgent, costly repairs. Being prepared for these potential delays helps ensure a smoother project timeline.

Financing Your Roofing Project

Financing your roofing project involves exploring various options, including:

  • Cash

  • Check

  • Credit card payments

  • Personal loans

  • Government-funded loans

Roofing contractors may offer payment plans or partner with third-party vendors for financing, reflecting their business credibility.

Secured financing options, such as home equity loans, typically offer lower interest rates but come with the risk of losing your home in case of default. Evaluating these options helps you choose the best financing method for your needs and budget, ensuring your roofing project can proceed without financial strain.

Recognizing Red Flags

Recognizing red flags in roofing contractors is crucial for avoiding scams and low-quality work. Be wary of contractors who:

  • Request large upfront payments

  • Lack of a physical business address

  • Use aggressive sales tactics

  • Seem too eager by offering great deals and immediate availability

These signs may signal desperation or a scam.

Contractors who drastically lower their bid to win the project may compromise on the quality of materials and labor, leading to long-term negative consequences for your roof. Ensure the contractor is bonded, meaning a bonding company has secured money for the consumer in case of a potential claim against the professional contractors.

By recognizing these red flags, you can avoid unreliable contractors and choose one that will provide quality work.

Navigating Post-Project Support

Post-installation support is crucial for ensuring the sustained performance of the roofing system after project completion. This support includes regular maintenance and prompt responses to any arising issues. Homeowners should expect good roofing contractors to provide post-installation support services as part of their follow-up.

Having a contractor who offers ongoing support and maintenance ensures that any issues can be addressed quickly and efficiently, maintaining the quality and longevity of your roof. This level of service is a hallmark of reputable roofing companies.

Local Advantages: Hiring a Roofer from Your Community

Hiring a local roofing contractor offers numerous advantages that can enhance the overall success of your roofing project. Local contractors are more likely to be familiar with local building codes and permit requirements, reducing the risk of non-compliance and ensuring that your project meets all necessary regulations. This knowledge helps streamline the process and prevents potential legal issues.

Additionally, local roofing contractors often have:

  • Established relationships with suppliers, which can result in cost savings and quicker access to materials

  • Proximity to provide more reliable and timely service

  • Incentive to deliver high-quality work to uphold a good reputation within the community

These factors make local roofing contractors an excellent choice for your roofing needs, including finding a potential contractor.


Choosing the right roofer is a multi-step process that requires careful consideration and due diligence. Each step is crucial in ensuring a successful roofing project, from assessing your roofing needs to verifying contractor credentials, requesting multiple estimates, and choosing the right materials. By following these smart tips, you can confidently select a roofer who will provide quality workmanship and long-term reliability, ensuring a solid roof over your head for years to come.

Frequently Asked Questions

How many estimates should I get before choosing a roofer?

It would be best to get at least two or three estimates from different contractors to compare pricing, timelines, and work details. This will help you make an informed decision.

What should I look for in a roofing contractor’s credentials?

When looking for a roofing contractor, ensure they are licensed and have liability and workers’ compensation insurance to protect you and your property from potential issues.

Why is it important to check a contractor’s past work and references?

It’s important to check a contractor’s past work and references because it helps verify their reliability and the quality of their work, ensuring they can meet your specific needs, whether it’s roofing or any other construction project.

What are some common red flags for roofing contractors to watch out for?

When hiring a roofing contractor, watch out for large upfront payments, lack of a physical business address, aggressive sales tactics, and drastically lowered bids. These can be red flags indicating potential issues with the contractor.

How can local roofing contractors benefit my project?

Hiring local roofing contractors can benefit your project by ensuring compliance with local building codes, accessing reliable suppliers, and obtaining high-quality work due to their investment in community reputation. This can ultimately lead to a smoother and more efficient roofing project.

5/5 - (1 vote)
Denis Tchernov
Main Contractor at ID Flat Roof

Denis is the driving force behind ID Flat Roof, a leading company in Boston specializing in flat roof repair and installation for over 20 years.
Denis excels in PVC, TPO, EPDM, and rubber roofing. His meticulous approach ensures quality and customer satisfaction.
Denis incorporates cutting-edge solutions like skylights and solar PV roofing.